The Makioka Sisters – Juni’chiro Tanizaki

Many things abound Tanazaki’s wonderful novel and yet I’m having a writer’s block to describe them. If I were to begin at the beginning, there are 4 Makioka sisters – Tsuruko, Sachiko, Yukiko and Taeko, all known for their youthfulness and beauty not to mention the by-gone splendor of Makioka wealth. While the novel was originally published in installments, the vintage edition contains all the parts.tms

Culture, family and family values dominate the story against the backdrop of WWII. The two older sisters – Tsuruko and Sachiko are married with children while the two youngest ones – Yukiko and Taeko are unmarried at the beginning of the novel. Despite the growing unease concerning the impending World War and escalating tensions with China, Tsuruko and Sachiko’s chief concerns remain to be Yukiko, Taeko and upholding their family’s traditions.

Tanizaki throws in a lot of cultural references which resonated to a certain extent with the Indian culture, perhaps a result of bygone cultural exchanges. The backdrop of this novel also references contemporary events such as the impending war in Europe, the second Sino-Japanese war, the Kobe flood of 1938 quite vividly. This was the positive aspect of the novel.

The sisters come across as stubborn, selfish and often times appear uncaring owing to the insular world in which they grew up. They find it difficult to adapt to the changing times, hate city life and Sachiko especially views her visits to Tokyo as ill-omen. The only character that’s somewhat endearing over time is Teinosuke, Sachiko’s level-headed but docile husband who often remains silent. Sachiko’s weakness is her sisters approval, which blinds her to their selfish natures. The fact that majority of the characters except Teinosuke were loosely based on Tanizaki’s third wives relations perhaps hints at his attempts to probably put his frustrations into words.

I made the mistake of watching the film version probably with high expectations only to have them dashed ruthlessly. The film was nowhere close to the novel and as R joked…the scripts of this film might have mixed up with the one of a soft porn! Best to be summarized as a terrible movie.

May 16 Reads

May just creeped up on me one fine Sunday…just when I was hoping to finish Alice McDermott’s tedious novel At Weddings and Wakes. I understand that one shouldn’t be too critical of an author but I’ll skip this step since one isn’t writing an essay thankfully.

may reads

At Weddings and Wakes is a slow paced novel that details every step of Lucy Towne’s 3 children, their observations of their mother’s interaction with her 3 Irish aunts – May, a former nun who always takes the children on walks and buys them presents; Agnes, the sophisticated and aloof aunt; Veronica, the youngest of the Towne sisters and an alcoholic. Added to this motley group is Momma, the formidable yet silent matriarch and the children’s father who often appears at the end of the visit only to pick up his wife and children. The children for their part, though bored with these often repetitive proceedings, were forced to go through the movements by their parents.

The story was so heavily inundated with whispered conversations as observed through the eyes of the 3 children. The source for the anxiety and unhappiness Lucy displayed, or for that matter, the source of the Towne women’s troubles remains a mystery as children are not supposed to understand. The characters are all given their own backdrop but it seems that they found solace in the repetitive nature of their actions . The only outsider who was let in on this heavy tableau was Lucy’s husband, portrayed as a cheerful fellow who patiently visits his in-laws and tries his best at playing a happy family.

To get over At Weddings and Wakes, I picked up Rick Riordan’s The Demigod Diaries. Written as a companion book to the Percy Jackson and the Heroes of Olympus series, the diary features an adventure each from Luke Castellan, Percy Jackson,  Jason Grace and Alabaster in their own narration. The first story serves as the premise for Luke and Thalia’s friendship with Annabeth, the second story narrates Percy and Annabeth’s quest for Hermes on their one month dating anniversary and the rest involve Jason and his girlfriend Piper. The entries include battling deadly monsters and meeting new demigods who are semi-villainous but the narration is infused with the wry humor that only the demigods can possess. It felt like reading a typical teenager’s diary on the whole and was quite refreshing.

As I prepared my TBR list based on reviews from Stuck in a book and Booksnob, I realized that I’ve never read Shirley Jackson’s books much less heard of her. So I decided that for May and June, I should probably read through as many of Jackson’s books as possible. So the book I chose for May is We Have Always Lived in a Castle. (Link to the review)

A long time friend suggested we start the read-along again, so I thought why not? It was my turn to suggest, so I picked the first book in PC Peter Grant series by Ben Aaronovitch. Aptly titled Midnight Riot, the plot is multi-threaded and not exactly strong. (Link to the review)

Next up was Up The Down Staircase by Bel Kaufman. Wish I’d simply bought the book on kindle flash sale but I didn’t. Instead I chose to read it as part of the kindle unlimited subscription. Kaufman highlights the declining plight of the US school system and feelings of apathy or despair shown by the average students of the public school system.

Here are some quotes from the book –

“We have keys but no locks (except in lavatories), blackboards but no chalk, students but no seats, teachers but no time to teach. The library is closed to the students.”

“The books we are required to teach frequently have nothing to do with anything except the fact that they have always been taught, or that there is an oversupply of them, or that some committee or the other was asked to come up with some titles.”

Kaufman’s experiences as school teacher and her interactions with students are delightfully showcased through the letters and observations of the protagonist, a newbie teach named Sylvia Barrett. The prose is witty with sardonic humor, the characters sketched are so universal that you’d find them in any country. It reminded me of my school days where teachers tried to teach us to the best of their abilities while balancing their varied admin duties. Kaufman’s characters were all there at my school as well, in some form or the other.

Midnight Riot – Ben Aaronovitch

Ben Aaronovitch’s Midnight Riot (PC Peter Grant-1) centers around the life and adventures of Peter Grant, a young apprentice wizard and a police constable with the Met. Following his encounter with a ghost while guarding the site of a macabre homicide, Peter’s investigations land him under the tutelage of Thomas Nightingale, head of the supernatural investigations branch and London’s only wizard in residence. Added to the crime investigation is the increasing tensions due to the long time feud between the river gods.rolba

The narrative was witty and light yet became an albeit boring walking guide to the streets and rivers of London. Then there are the undertones of racial profiling as the plot progresses. The anthropomorphic river spirits and gods’ and their petty disputes forms a sub plot and rapidly overtakes the primary plot which involves chasing a revenant spirit and a vengeful ghost. This is further muddled by a brief meeting with vampires who serve as the extras in this delightful novel. And Peter’s attempts at a crash course in magic won’t mean much unless you’ve experienced the wonderful world of Harry Potter. While JK Rowling didn’t go overboard in her attempts to explain magic, her description of the outcome of a spell was enough to connect to the Latin wording. Here, Aaronovitch attempted to amalgamate science with magic, which rendered the entire concept ambiguous and took the charm out of magic.

As for monsters, they appeared to the principal cast while Nightingale seemed like an extra in an epic movie on monsters. And there are the key terms constantly referenced “Lux” and “Vestigia” which overwhelm the plot so much so that I speed read the rest of the book closing my mind off from these terms. In the end, these didn’t mean much since any normal police procedural would involve an armed detective and plenty of clues for a sharp mind to close in on.

Constant references to Harry Potter gave plenty of evidence of Aaronovitch’s source of inspiration but not maintaining the plot at an even pace made this novel flat. I know I sound critical but it gets difficult to praise a novel all the time even when you don’t like it much. I suspect that the reason for its popularity stems from a lack of Harry Potterish characters in the market and Peter Grant, while not perfect seems to cut very close.